Home > News > Wood Burning Stoves vs Fireplaces

Wood Burning Stoves vs Fireplaces

by | Mar 15, 2023

Wood-burning stoves and fireplaces are both popular choices for heating and creating a cozy atmosphere in a home. However, there are some key differences between the two that may influence which one is the better choice for your particular needs.

  1. Efficiency: Wood-burning stoves are generally more efficient than fireplaces because they are designed to burn wood more completely and to radiate heat more effectively. This means that wood stoves can heat a room more efficiently than a fireplace.
  2. Heat Output: Wood-burning stoves can produce more heat than fireplaces. Wood stoves are designed to heat a specific area of a home and radiate heat throughout the room. Fireplaces, on the other hand, can lose a lot of heat up the chimney and can be less effective at heating a room.
  3. Installation: Wood-burning stoves are generally easier to install than fireplaces. Most wood stoves can be installed in an existing chimney, whereas a fireplace may require additional construction work.
  4. Safety: Both wood stoves and fireplaces can be dangerous if not used properly. However, wood stoves are generally considered safer because they are designed to contain the fire within the stove and have fewer open flames. Fireplaces can pose a greater risk of sparks and embers that can cause a fire.
  5. Aesthetics: Fireplaces are often considered more aesthetically pleasing than wood-burning stoves because of their classic look and feel. Fireplaces can also be used for decorative purposes, even when not in use.

The best wood for a wood-burning stove is dry, seasoned hardwood. Hardwood, such as oak, maple, hickory, or ash, is more dense and provides a longer burn time and more heat compared to softwood like pine or spruce, which burn faster and with less heat.

It’s important to use properly seasoned wood in your wood stove, which means that the wood has been cut, split, and dried for at least 6 to 12 months. This allows the wood to dry out, reducing its moisture content, which makes it easier to light and burn more efficiently. Unseasoned or “green” wood contains a lot of moisture, which can create excess smoke, creosote buildup in the stove and chimney, and cause more frequent cleaning requirements.

Other types of wood to avoid in a wood-burning stove are those with a lot of resin, such as pine or fir, as this can create more creosote buildup and potential for chimney fires. Also, do not burn treated or painted wood, which can release harmful chemicals into the air.

Overall, using dry, seasoned hardwood is the best choice for your wood stove to provide efficient heating and reduce the risk of dangerous creosote buildup in your stove and chimney.

The best wood for an indoor fireplace is also dry, seasoned hardwood. The same types of hardwood that are recommended for a wood stove, such as oak, maple, hickory, or ash, will work well for a fireplace. Hardwood will produce a hot, clean-burning fire with minimal smoke, soot, or creosote buildup.

It’s important to use properly seasoned wood, as wet or green wood will not burn efficiently and will produce more smoke and soot, which can create harmful particulate matter that can be breathed in. Properly seasoned wood should have a moisture content of less than 20%.

It’s also important to avoid using softwoods like pine or fir indoors, as they produce more creosote buildup, which can create a fire hazard in the chimney.

Overall, using dry, seasoned hardwood is the best choice for an indoor fireplace as it produces a hot, clean-burning fire with minimal smoke and soot, creating a cozy and safe environment for your home.

When choosing firewood for either, it’s important to ensure it is sustainably sourced and has been properly seasoned. You can purchase seasoned firewood from a reputable supplier, or you can season your own by cutting and splitting the wood and storing it in a dry, well-ventilated area for at least six months to a year.

Ultimately, the choice between a wood-burning stove and a fireplace will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Consider factors such as the size of the room you want to heat, your budget, and your aesthetic preferences.


About Timber Ridge Firewood

Timber Ridge Firewood is a family-owned and operated firewood company that offers our services to Calgary and surrounding areas. Nicholas and Steven Boivin are the founders and owners of the company. We work diligently to create the easiest and best firewood experience for all of our clients.